Blog ยท
AI transparency: when should your brand disclose it?
Dior sold a film as 'all hand-drawn' and the internet found extra fingers. When should a brand disclose AI use, and why hiding costs more than owning it.
When should a brand disclose that it used AI? Short answer: whenever hiding it could become the story. The long answer goes through Paris, a shape-shifting dog collar and the most talked-about holiday film of the year.
Dior's "all hand-drawn" film
In early November 2026, Dior released Christian Dior's Night in Color, its holiday film: an animation directed by Sylvain Chomet, the Oscar-nominated director of The Triplets of Belleville, narrated by Robert Pattinson, with Rihanna as the lucky star. The marketing made a point of one detail: all hand-drawn, using techniques that go back to the 1940s. Seven months of production, a team of 20 artists.
The film is beautiful. But within days, the internet did what the internet does: paused it frame by frame. Extra fingers, a collar that changes shape between scenes, a blurry star at the top of the tree. And just like that, the AI accusations went viral.
The production answered: no generative AI, but yes, an "automated interpolation system" generated some of the in-between frames. Which system, exactly? They didn't say. And the conversation changed. The question stopped being "is it AI or not?" and became a much worse one for the brand: "then why 'all hand-drawn'?".
The problem isn't the tool. It's the promise
Notice: nobody attacked Dior for using technology. The damage came from the gap between the claim and the process. When a luxury brand turns "handmade" into a selling point, every frame becomes a promise. And in communication, a broken promise costs more than any tool. Some even gave the episode a name: "craftwashing", dressing automation up as craft.
And it's not just a feeling. In a 2026 study run in the US and Canada (AI Slop or Not?, by Zefr and OM Media Trials), 41% of consumers say they feel more positive about a brand when AI content is clearly labelled. The same study shows the reverse: when people can't tell whether something was made by AI or by humans, favourability, trust and purchase intent drop. In short: doubt charges more than truth.
"But doesn't disclosing devalue the work?"
That's the fear, we know. The Dior case shows the opposite path: what devalues the work isn't the tool, it's the secret. If the film had been presented as "traditional 2D animation, with computer-assisted interpolation on some frames", hardly anyone would have paused the video to hunt for fingers. The collective zoom only started because the promise was absolute.
Regulation is closing in too: in the European Union, the AI Act's transparency rules have applied since August 2026, and AI-generated or AI-manipulated content must be identified (with exceptions, for instance for clearly artistic works, and that borderline is exactly where the debate sits). In Brazil, AI regulation is still being discussed in Congress. What is a communication choice today may be an obligation tomorrow.
Three questions before you publish
To decide whether you need to disclose, here's a quick test:
- If someone asks, does the answer embarrass you? If the team would rather nobody asked how the piece was made, you have your answer.
- Did AI help the process, or did it make the result? Using AI to research references and test directions is process. Generating the final image your audience sees is result, and that's where transparency matters most.
- Is "handmade" (or "100% real") the selling point? If authenticity is the promise, any hidden automation is a ticking clock.
How we handle it
Studio Shoyu uses AI and says so. We have a whole page about our AI videos explaining what the tool does and what stays in the team's hands: script, art direction, editing and finishing. And we still draw and animate the old way in our motion design work when a project calls for a human line.
What never changes, either way, is the answer when a client asks "how did you make this?": the true one. No project has ever looked smaller because of it. Quite the opposite: a client who knows what they're buying trusts the result more.
If your brand is stuck between the fear of looking "robot-made" and the fear of looking outdated, talk to us. Around here, transparency isn't a risk. It's an edge.